Who Pays Real Estate Agent Fees (and How Do Commissions Work Now)?

Who Pays Real Estate Agent Fees (and How Do Commissions Work Now)?

Each side in a U.S. home sale is contractually responsible for its own agent's fee under separate written agreements: the seller pays the listing brokerage per the listing contract, and the buyer sets buyer-broker compensation in writing before touring homes. Following the August 17, 2024 National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) practice changes, offers of compensation can no longer appear on the MLS, yet sellers can still agree to fund buyer-broker fees off-MLS or through purchase-contract concessions. Average buyer-agent commissions on closed sales stood at 2.42% in Q3 2025 (Redfin).

A sunlit escrow closing room with tan leather chairs around a light-oak conference table, two closed leather portfolios on opposite sides beside a stoneware water pitcher and glasses, and tall windows overlooking a tree-lined residential street.

Key takeaways

  • Separate listing and buyer-broker compensation: Negotiate the listing fee independently in the listing agreement, and treat any buyer-broker compensation or concession as a separate, written seller decision.

  • Explain why financed buyers request seller concessions: Show sellers that buyers cannot roll agent fees into a mortgage loan amount, while Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and VA exclude customary seller-paid buyer-broker fees from seller concession caps.

  • Compare compensation options on net proceeds: Put a three-scenario net-proceeds comparison on screen so sellers weigh a negotiated buyer-broker concession against the equity lost if a listing sits and requires a price adjustment.

  • Standardize compliant net-proceeds walkthroughs: Equip every agent on a team or brokerage with live Seller Presentation net proceeds so no one leans on outdated pre-2024 scripts when a seller pushes back on fees.

When a seller asks "who pays the real estate fees?" at a listing appointment, outdated scripts claiming "the seller always pays 6 percent" fail both compliance standards and client trust. Today, each side contracts for its own agent's compensation in writing, yet sellers still frequently fund buyer-broker fees through off-MLS offers or purchase-contract concessions because buyers cannot finance commissions into a mortgage. Walking a seller through the exact rules and walk-away net proceeds turns a fee objection into a calm business decision.

Who pays the real estate agent fees when buying or selling a house?

By contract, each party in a home sale is responsible for paying its own brokerage: the seller pays the listing brokerage out of closing proceeds under the listing agreement, and the buyer agrees to buyer-broker compensation in a written agreement before touring homes. In practice, sellers still cover or contribute toward the buyer's brokerage fee in many transactions, either through an off-MLS offer of compensation or a concession requested inside the buyer's purchase offer.

Real estate agent fees flow through brokerages at settlement, not directly to individual agents. Escrow or the closing attorney deducts seller-paid compensation from closing proceeds and wires it to each brokerage, which pays its agent under their brokerage split. When a buyer pays their agent directly, that fee is paid in cash at closing.

When a seller asks why they should consider paying the buyer's agent, verbal explanations and static CMA printouts put the agent on the defensive. Modern listing presentation tools like Stairtop build live seller net proceeds from MLS data inside an interactive Seller Presentation in about a minute, letting the agent model listing and buyer-side compensation beside comps and timing.

What changed after the August 2024 NAR settlement practice changes?

Effective August 17, 2024, practice changes from the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) settlement removed offers of buyer-broker compensation from the MLS and required MLS participants working with buyers to sign written fee agreements before touring homes (NAR Broker-to-Broker Agreements 101; NAR Written Buyer Agreements 101). Brokerage commissions remain negotiable, and sellers can still fund buyer-broker compensation off-MLS or inside the purchase contract.

Rule Area

Before August 17, 2024

After August 17, 2024

What Stayed the Same

MLS Compensation Fields

Cooperative compensation offers appeared in dedicated MLS fields

Broker compensation fields are prohibited on covered MLSs (NAR)

Off-MLS offers remain allowed via websites, flyers, emails, signs, or broker-to-broker agreements

Buyer-Broker Agreements

Written buyer agreements were optional in many states before touring

MLS participants must sign a written buyer agreement before touring in person or live virtually (NAR)

Open-house visitors speaking with a listing agent do not need a written agreement

Fee Cap & Precision

Buyer-side fees were often tied to the MLS cooperative offer

Agreements must state an objectively ascertainable rate or dollar fee; buyer brokers cannot accept more from any source (NAR)

Fee structures stay flexible: percentage, flat fee, hourly fee, or $0

Seller Consent

Cooperative splits were often bundled inside one listing fee

Listing brokers must obtain advance written seller approval specifying any payment or offer to a buyer broker (NAR)

The seller chooses whether to offer compensation, wait for offers, or decline

Seller Concessions on MLS

Used mainly for closing costs, repairs, or rate buydowns

General buyer concessions may still appear on the MLS if not tied to paying a buyer broker (NAR)

Commissions are not set by law and remain fully negotiable

Two compliance rules trip up agents most often: written buyer agreements cannot use open-ended wording like "whatever the seller is offering," and a buyer broker may never collect more from any source than the amount written in that agreement (NAR Compensation, Commission and Concessions).

What is the average real estate agent commission right now?

Real estate agent commissions are not set by law and vary by market and price point, with closed-sale buyer-side fees averaging 2.42% nationwide in Q3 2025 (Redfin News) and agent-reported combined rates averaging 5.46% in August 2026 (Clever Real Estate). Despite predictions that rates would collapse after August 2024, actual transaction data shows negotiated fees stayed near pre-settlement ranges.

  • Closed buyer-side transactions: Redfin's Q3 2025 analysis recorded a 2.42% average U.S. buyer-agent commission, up slightly from 2.36% in Q3 2024 (Redfin News). By price tier, buyer-agent fees averaged 2.52% under $500,000, 2.32% from $500,000 to $999,999, and 2.22% at $1 million or above.

  • National agent survey totals: Clever Real Estate's August 2026 survey of 434 U.S. agents reported a 5.46% combined average (2.76% listing side, 2.70% buyer side), with state averages ranging from 4.62% to 6.00% (Clever Real Estate).

For the full commission-to-net equation and how each $10,000 price move changes walk-away cash, see our real estate commission calculator guide.

Can a buyer roll agent fees into a mortgage or request them as a seller concession?

No, current mortgage regulations do not allow buyers to finance real estate agent commissions directly into a mortgage loan amount (NAR Practice Changes Take Effect). Because a buyer putting 3.5 to 10 percent down rarely has an extra $12,000 to $18,000 in cash to pay their agent on top of closing costs, most financed buyers request seller-paid compensation inside their offer.

Major mortgage agencies confirmed how seller-paid buyer-broker fees are treated in underwriting:

  • Fannie Mae (Conventional): Selling Guide B3-4.1-02 caps Interested Party Contributions (IPCs) at 2% to 9% of property value, and Fannie Mae's April 15, 2024 Selling Notice confirmed customary seller-paid buyer-agent commissions do not count toward IPC limits.

  • Freddie Mac (Conventional): Freddie Mac's June 5, 2024 Buyer Agent Commissions FAQ confirmed customary seller-paid buyer-agent fees stay excluded from financing concession caps.

  • VA Home Loans: VA Circular 26-24-14 (effective August 10, 2024) lets Veterans pay reasonable buyer-broker fees from liquid assets (never rolled into the loan) while confirming sellers may still pay them outside VA seller concession limits.

Because customary seller-paid buyer-broker fees sit outside IPC caps, a seller can fund buyer-broker compensation without crowding out closing-cost credits or a rate buydown.

How do different buyer-broker compensation structures change seller net proceeds?

Comparing compensation options on a reconciled seller net sheet shows sellers that protecting walk-away equity depends on total net dollars and days on market, not just avoiding a buyer-broker line item.

The table below models an illustrative, market-neutral $600,000 home sale across three structures. All commission rates are illustrative examples only; commissions are negotiable and not set by law. Assumptions: $300,000 verified mortgage payoff, $6,000 in estimated title, escrow, transfer tax, and recording fees, a 2.5 percent listing fee, and $2,500 per month in non-principal carrying costs (interest, taxes, insurance, utilities) if the home sits 60 extra days.

Seller Net-Proceeds Line Item

Option A: Offer 2.5 Percent Concession

Option B: Offer 0 Percent Up Front, Negotiate 2 Percent

Option C: Refuse Fees, Sit 60 Days & Adjust

Contract Sale Price

$600,000

$600,000

$575,000

Listing-Side Fee (2.5 percent)

-$15,000

-$15,000

-$14,375

Buyer-Broker Compensation

-$15,000 (2.5 percent)

-$12,000 (2 percent)

$0

Estimated Closing Costs & Tax

-$6,000

-$6,000

-$6,000

Verified Mortgage Payoff

-$300,000

-$300,000

-$300,000

Extra 60 Days Carry

$0

$0

-$5,000

Total Deductions & Carry

-$336,000

-$333,000

-$325,375

Estimated Seller Net

$264,000 (Baseline)

$267,000 (+$3,000)

$249,625 (-$14,375)

Buyer-Pool & Timing Risk

Broadest financed buyer pool

High net if open to offer requests

Shrinks buyer pool; forces $25,000 price adjustment

Option B shows why many sellers skip an up-front offer and negotiate buyer-broker compensation inside incoming offers: if a buyer's agreement sets their agent's fee at 2 percent, the seller nets $267,000, or $3,000 more than committing 2.5 percent up front. Option C shows the risk of refusing concessions outright: shrinking the financed buyer pool and sitting 60 extra days before a $25,000 price adjustment drops seller net to $249,625, which is $14,375 less than Option A even with $0 paid to the buyer's brokerage. For a full closing checklist, see our seller net sheet guide.

Static CMA PDFs and spreadsheets stall when a seller asks, "What if we list at $620,000 and offer 2 percent?" Inside a Stairtop Seller Presentation, the agent adjusts listing and buyer-broker compensation live while dragging the asking price along the time-to-offer curve, where predicted days to pending land within about 6 days of actual outcomes on average.

How should listing agents explain buyer-broker compensation at a listing appointment?

Present your listing fee and buyer-broker compensation as two separate, negotiable decisions, then anchor the seller to net proceeds across incoming offers rather than a gross percentage. Never imply a "standard" rate, and never claim buyers will skip the home without an up-front offer. Explain the cash-to-close mechanics calmly and let the seller choose.

Compliant verbatim talk track for the listing table:

"Before we look at numbers, every real estate commission is fully negotiable and never set by law. Today we are making two separate decisions. First is the fee you agree to pay my brokerage to market, negotiate, and manage your sale, so let's confirm that line first. Second is how you want to handle buyer-broker compensation. Offers of compensation no longer go on the MLS, and every represented buyer now signs a written fee agreement before touring. Because mortgage rules do not let buyers roll agent fees into their loan, many financed buyers ask the seller to cover their agent's fee as a concession in the offer. You do not have to set a fixed buyer-broker number today if you prefer to evaluate each offer on its bottom-line net. Whether an offer arrives at $600,000 asking for a 2 percent concession or $588,000 with no concession, we judge every offer on the check you deposit at closing."

For managing brokers and team leaders, improvising this conversation creates compliance and inventory risk. When agents rely on static office CMA templates that cannot recalculate live, some slip into pre-2024 language while others overprice listings to absorb fees. Rolling out a shared Stairtop Seller Presentation workflow keeps every agent on the same compliant net-proceeds standard. See what goes into a modern real estate listing presentation for the full appointment structure.

How does Stairtop handle commission and net-proceeds conversations in the room?

Before a listing appointment, you enter the property address in Stairtop to generate an interactive Seller Presentation from live MLS data in about a minute, complete with curated comps, photo notes, and a live seller net proceeds panel pre-loaded with public-record mortgage payoff estimates.

When the seller asks how listing fees or a buyer-broker concession will change their walk-away check, you adjust listing commission, buyer-side compensation, closing costs, and mortgage payoff live on screen while dragging the asking price along the time-to-offer curve. The seller watches their estimated net proceeds and predicted pending date update together in real time, so market evidence makes the case instead of an awkward fee debate. Across Stairtop Seller Presentation listings, 93% sold faster than the market median.

Solo agents can preview a Seller Presentation with live net proceeds at app.stairtop.com/try. Team leaders and managing brokers standardizing pricing and net-proceeds conversations across every agent can request a brokerage demo.

Frequently asked questions

Who pays the real estate agent fees when buying or selling a house?

By contract, each party is responsible for compensating its own brokerage. The seller pays the listing brokerage out of closing proceeds under the listing agreement, and the buyer agrees to buyer-broker compensation in a written agreement signed before touring homes. In practice, many buyers ask the seller to cover buyer-broker compensation through an off-MLS offer or a purchase-contract concession, which the seller can accept, counter, or decline.

What is the average real estate agent commission?

Commission rates are not set by law and are fully negotiable on every transaction. Across closed U.S. sales in Q3 2025, Redfin measured an average buyer-agent commission of 2.42%, ranging from 2.52% on homes under $500,000 to 2.22% on homes at $1 million or above. In Clever Real Estate's August 2026 survey of 434 agents, reported total commissions averaged 5.46%, split between 2.76% for listing agents and 2.70% for buyer agents.

Do sellers still pay the buyer's agent after the NAR settlement?

Sellers are never required to pay a buyer's agent, and since August 17, 2024, offers of compensation cannot be published on the MLS. However, sellers may still choose to pay buyer-broker compensation through off-MLS marketing, a broker-to-broker agreement, or a seller concession negotiated in the purchase offer. Many sellers continue to consider these requests because covering buyer-broker fees keeps cash-constrained financed buyers in the buyer pool.

Are real estate agent commissions negotiable?

Yes, real estate agent commissions are not fixed by law or by any trade association, and every fee structure is negotiable between the client and their brokerage. Both listing agreements and mandatory written buyer agreements must conspicuously disclose that broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. Agents and clients may agree to a percentage of the sale price, a flat fee, or another objectively ascertainable structure.

Can a buyer roll agent fees into their mortgage or request them as a seller concession?

Current mortgage regulations do not allow buyers to finance real estate agent commissions directly into the mortgage loan amount. Instead, buyers who lack extra cash at closing typically request that the seller pay buyer-broker compensation or provide a closing concession inside the purchase offer. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the VA all confirm that customary seller-paid buyer-broker fees are excluded from standard seller concession limits.

How do listing agents explain buyer-broker compensation to sellers?

Listing agents should explain the listing fee first, state clearly that all brokerage fees are negotiable, and then present buyer-broker compensation as a business choice tied to buyer demand and bottom-line net proceeds. Comparing walk-away cash across scenarios (offering a concession up front, evaluating requests inside offers, or refusing concessions) lets the numbers guide the decision instead of putting the agent on the defensive.

Related guides