How Accurate Is the Redfin Estimate vs. Zillow Zestimate?

How Accurate Is the Redfin Estimate vs. Zillow Zestimate?

According to Redfin's accuracy table updated November 20, 2026, the Redfin Estimate has a nationwide median error rate of 1.95% for on-market homes and 7.70% for off-market homes. Zillow's Zestimate, refreshed November 8, 2026, reports a comparable 1.80% on-market median error and 7.21% off-market median error. For listing agents, the off-market figure is the one that matters at a listing appointment: before a home hits the MLS, half of all portal estimates miss the eventual sale price by more than 7%.

A sunlit renovated kitchen and open dining area with white oak cabinetry, a honed marble island, and French doors opening to a green backyard, showing the interior condition and upgrades automated home value estimates cannot see.

Every listing agent has walked into a kitchen-table appointment where the seller already has a portal estimate pulled up on their phone. As of November 2026, the Redfin Estimate carries a nationwide median error rate of 1.95% for on-market homes and 7.70% for off-market homes, while the Zillow Zestimate reports 1.80% on-market and 7.21% off-market. Because sellers look up their address before it hits the MLS, they are anchoring to an off-market estimate where half of all predictions miss the eventual sale price by more than seven percent.

How accurate is the Redfin Estimate compared to the Zillow Zestimate?

The Redfin Estimate and Zillow Zestimate perform almost identically at the national level, with both models landing under two percent median error once a home is listed and above seven percent median error before it hits the market.

Metric

Redfin Estimate

Zillow Zestimate

On-market median error

1.95%

1.80%

Off-market median error

7.70%

7.21%

Off-market within 5% of sale price

35.79%

Not published on main table

Off-market within 10% of sale price

59.21%

Not published on main table

Off-market within 20% of sale price

81.04%

Not published on main table

U.S. homes covered

92 million

120+ million

Update frequency

Daily (on-market); weekly (off-market)

Multiple times per week

Primary source

Redfin Estimate (updated Nov 20, 2026)

Zillow Zestimate (refreshed Nov 8, 2026)

Both portals report median error, not maximum error. A 7.70% off-market median error on Redfin means half of off-market estimates land within 7.70% of the final sale price and the other half miss by more. On a $500,000 house, that midpoint miss is $38,500 in either direction.

That gap is where listing appointments stall. When an agent brushes off a portal estimate or hands over a static CMA printout, the seller hears one opinion competing against a national algorithm. Modern pricing software like Stairtop solves that moment by building an interactive Seller Presentation from live MLS data in about a minute, putting curated comps and predicted days to pending on screen so the market makes the case instead of the agent.

Why is the on-market error rate misleading at a listing appointment?

The headline on-market error rate is misleading before a home is listed because portals measure active accuracy only after an agent's list price, MLS remarks, and current market activity are already feeding the algorithm.

Zillow's methodology page states this directly: "For homes that are listed for sale, we evaluate accuracy by comparing the Zestimate shown before the home goes pending with the final recorded sale price." The tight 1.80% figure reflects the last Zestimate displayed right before the property goes under contract, after the listing has already absorbed price adjustments, buyer activity, and agent-entered MLS details.

Before you sign the listing agreement, none of that signal exists. The seller is looking at the off-market estimate, where the spread widens sharply. In Redfin's national off-market table covering 135,658,881 estimates as of November 20, 2026, only 35.79% landed within 5% of the eventual sale price, 59.21% landed within 10%, and 81.04% landed within 20% (Redfin accuracy data). Nearly one in five off-market estimates missed the final sale price by more than 20%.

For a listing agent, that distinction reframes the conversation without attacking the portal. Explain that the tight on-market accuracy figure applies after a home is listed on the MLS, whereas today's pre-listing number is an off-market estimate with a wide statistical range.

What data do Redfin and Zillow use, and when are estimates least reliable?

Both Redfin and Zillow are automated valuation models (AVMs) that combine public records, tax assessments, and MLS feeds, making them useful for broad neighborhood trends and unreliable for individual condition or micro-location.

An automated valuation model is a computer-generated value that uses mathematical models to compare basic property facts (bedrooms, bathrooms, square footage) against recent area sales and market trends, as defined by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB). Each portal weights those inputs differently:

  • Redfin Estimate: As a licensed brokerage, Redfin pulls direct MLS data on recently sold homes and factors in more than 500 data points about the home, neighborhood, and market across 92 million U.S. properties. It publishes an estimate only for single-family homes, townhouses, and condos with enough similar nearby sales in the past year.

  • Zillow Zestimate: Zillow runs a neural network model across more than 120 million homes using county and tax assessor records, direct MLS feeds, user-submitted home facts, listing history, and seasonal demand trends. Zillow excludes foreclosure resales and notes that when local sales are scarce, its model extrapolates from a geography up to the size of an entire county.

That structural difference explains why a Redfin Estimate and a Zestimate can diverge by tens of thousands of dollars on the same address, and why both differ from an appraisal or a comparative market analysis (CMA). A licensed appraiser inspects the home in person and adjusts line by line against verified comps. Even in mortgage lending, federal regulators adopted final AVM quality control standards effective October 1, 2025, requiring random sample testing and oversight whenever lenders rely on automated models.

Portal estimates break down most often in five situations:

  1. Unrecorded upgrades or deferred maintenance. Renovations missing from tax records or the MLS do not register. A dated 1990s interior and a $120,000 remodel with the same square footage look identical in county data.

  2. Micro-location boundaries. Backing to a busy road, sitting inside a top-rated school boundary, or having an unobstructed view shifts buyer demand far more than a county-level model captures.

  3. Unique or custom properties. AVMs work best in uniform subdivisions with steady turnover; custom floor plans, ADUs, and acreage lots break comp matching.

  4. Incorrect public records. Missing bathrooms, unpermitted square footage, or wrong lot sizes feed directly into the estimate.

  5. Shifting local markets. Closed MLS sales reflect contracts written 30 to 60 days earlier, so backward-looking models lag current inventory and buyer demand.

How should an agent handle a seller anchored to a Redfin Estimate or Zestimate?

Treat the portal estimate as a starting data point, test it immediately against tight local comps, and let the comp range determine your next move.

Agents typically make one of two mistakes when a seller quotes a Redfin Estimate or Zestimate: dismissing it outright ("Zillow is always wrong"), which makes the seller defensive, or dropping a 30-page static CMA binder on the table and arguing comp by comp. Run this 5-step decision framework instead.

Step

What to check

Action in the room

1. Note the portal estimate and its range

Look up both the Redfin Estimate and Zillow Zestimate, plus the published high-to-low value range.

Write the seller's number down without arguing. Point out the portal's own range so the seller sees the model expects variance.

2. Pull tight closed and active comps

Pull recently closed sales and active competition within a tight radius and recent window, matching beds, baths, square footage, and lot type.

Show what buyers actually closed on and what they can tour this weekend. See how real estate comps work for tighter comp selection.

3. Estimate sits inside the comp range

The portal number falls cleanly inside your adjusted comp bracket.

Validate the estimate ("The algorithm landed right in line with recent sales") and move straight to launch pricing strategy and timing.

4. Estimate sits well above comps

The portal number sits above recent closed sales or matches only fully renovated comps.

Walk through interior photos of the top comps to show the condition gap, then show higher-priced listings that sat on the market or took a price cut.

5. Estimate sits below comps

The portal number undervalues the property relative to recent neighborhood sales.

Flag the undervaluation immediately, verify recent permitted or unrecorded upgrades, and show the comps supporting a stronger list price.

Step 2 and Step 4 are where manual spreadsheets and static PDF exports slow you down. Pulling MLS exports, sorting photos to prove condition gaps, and explaining how an extra $30,000 stretches days on market takes an hour by hand and still looks flat on paper. With Stairtop, curated comps arrive with photo-based condition notes attached, so the seller sees the condition gap visually instead of taking your word for it. For setting the final launch price once you have the bracket, see how to price a home to sell.

What should you say when a portal estimate is higher than the comps?

Validate why the seller checked the portal, explain the off-market margin of error in plain language, and hand the hard news to the comparable sales and photos.

Here is a verbatim Step 4 talk track for a seller quoting a $645,000 Redfin Estimate on a home whose comp bracket is $595,000 to $610,000:

"I pulled up that $645,000 Redfin Estimate before I came over, and I'm glad you brought it up because buyers look at the exact same page. Redfin publishes its own accuracy data: once a house is already listed on the MLS, the estimate is tight, within about two percent. Before a house hits the market, though, their median error is nearly eight percent, which on a house in this range is roughly $45,000 to $50,000 either way because the computer hasn't walked through your front door.

>

Let's look at the three homes buyers will compare yours to this weekend. The home on Maple Street that closed at $615,000 had a brand-new kitchen and primary bath, and you can see it right here in the photos. The home on Cedar Avenue tried testing the market at $640,000, right near that online estimate, sat for 48 days, and had to take a price cut down to $605,000 before it went under contract.

>

My job isn't to talk you down. It's to make sure you don't end up as the listing that helps your neighbor sell. If we price inside the $595,000 to $610,000 range where buyers are writing offers right now, we protect your timeline and your final net."

This script never attacks the seller's number and never asks the seller to trust your opinion over a computer. The portal's own off-market error sets the frame, the comp photos prove the condition gap, and the neighbor that sat 48 days proves the cost of overpricing. Pairing that conversation with a live price-to-timing curve in Stairtop lets the seller drag the price from $645,000 to $605,000 and watch predicted days to pending and net proceeds shift together.

How do you replace an online estimate in a Stairtop Seller Presentation?

Enter the property address in Stairtop before your appointment to build a live Seller Presentation directly from MLS data in about a minute.

When the seller brings up their Redfin Estimate or Zestimate, open the presentation on your laptop or tablet instead of a static CMA binder. Walk through the curated comps together—each showing price spread, days on market, similarity, and a concise condition note drawn from listing photos—so the seller sees how buyers will compare their home to recent sales.

Then open the live time-to-offer curve. Drag the list price up to the seller's portal estimate and watch the predicted pending date stretch out, then drag it into the comp-supported range and watch predicted days to pending and live seller net proceeds tighten in real time. Across Stairtop Seller Presentations, 93% of listings sold faster than the market median and 25% were less likely to need a price improvement. For the full appointment flow, see what goes into a modern real estate listing presentation.

What to do before your next listing appointment

Look up both the Redfin Estimate and Zillow Zestimate before every listing appointment so you are never caught off guard at the kitchen table, then build your pricing plan around verified condition and active competition. Preview a live Seller Presentation for your next listing address in about a minute at app.stairtop.com/try.

Frequently asked questions

How accurate is the Redfin Estimate?

Redfin reports a nationwide median error rate of 1.95% for active on-market listings and 7.70% for off-market homes, per its accuracy table updated November 20, 2026. That means half of off-market Redfin Estimates land within 7.70% of the eventual sale price, and half miss by more than 7.70%. Only 35.79% of off-market Redfin Estimates fall within 5% of the final sale price.

Is Zillow's Zestimate or Redfin's estimate more accurate?

Their published national error rates are very close. As of November 2026, Zillow reports a 1.80% on-market and 7.21% off-market median error, while Redfin reports 1.95% on-market and 7.70% off-market. Because each company measures accuracy on its own footprint and schedule, neither wins in every neighborhood; local comp density and record accuracy determine which one is closer on a given street.

Why does the Redfin Estimate differ from an appraisal or recent neighborhood sales?

An automated valuation model (AVM) calculates value from public records, tax data, and nearby sales without stepping inside the house. A licensed appraiser inspects the property in person and makes feature-by-feature adjustments against comparable sales, while a local listing agent also accounts for active competition, layout, and buyer demand today.

What data do Redfin and Zillow use to calculate home value estimates?

Redfin combines direct MLS data on recently sold homes with more than 500 data points about the home, neighborhood, and market across 92 million U.S. homes. Zillow runs a neural network model across more than 120 million homes using county and tax assessor records, direct MLS feeds, user-submitted home facts, listing activity, and broader county-level market trends.

What should an agent do when a seller is anchored to a Redfin Estimate or Zestimate?

Start by noting the estimate and its published value range rather than dismissing it outright. Then compare it against tightly matched recent closed and active comps, walking through interior photos and days on market so the market data, not your personal opinion, explains any gap.

When are online home value estimates least reliable?

Portal estimates are least reliable on off-market homes with unrecorded renovations or deferred maintenance, custom or unique properties, rural or low-turnover areas with few recent sales, and rapidly shifting markets where closed sales lag current buyer demand. Micro-location factors like a busy road, view, or school boundary also widen the error.